Welcome to Little Italy Pizzeria & Restaurant Saranac Lake
Little Italy Pizzeria & Restaurant in Saranac Lake invites diners to experience a delightful blend of traditional Italian flavors and warm hospitality. Nestled at 151 River St, this cozy eatery offers an inviting atmosphere, complete with a dining area featuring high ceilings and soothing rock music. While known for delicious pizzas, the menu extends to baked pasta, subs, and standout desserts, including a “killer” cannoli. With a cash-only policy and attentive service, patrons can enjoy quick meals alongside a selection of craft beers. Little Italy stands out as a hidden gem, promising satisfying meals in a charming setting.
Little Italy Pizzeria & Restaurant Saranac Lake: Reviews & Ratings
Got a pizza to go. Decent pie. Fast service has a good beer on tap to wait. A little pricey but worth it
Delicious food. Restuarant does not take credit cards. Also even though the restuarant is a Pizzeria, you cannot get slices if you come for sit down service. We ordered italian food and salad and wanted a slice of pizza. Not possible but you can get it on the way out.
Everything was great; the food and service 5 out of 5, can’t wait to be back. Thank you!
We loved our waiter sky. She was amazing. We’ll definitely be back!! Thanks for a good meal.
CASH ONLY, ATM and WiFi inside. Upon walking in on a late evening on a Monday during week one of “spring break,” I was thinking, “it’s a pizzeria.” Well, I wasn’t wrong, but there was a lot more to it. I saw a couple of booths up front, but then I was asked if I wanted to sit in the back, I agreed and was surprised to see a dining area. It was cozy but open and had tall ceilings. The air smelled fresh and they were playing rock and soft rock through their speakers, but not too loud or not at all, and it made me feel at ease. I was expecting a pizza menu with finger food, but was pleasantly surprised at what other dishes they had on the menu. Baked pasta, pasta, salads, appetizers, subs both hot and cold, and desserts. ***This review is not based on their pizza, but instead, their delicious daily special and *killer* dessert. Tonight I had the Shrimp Genovese with artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, and broccoli on linguine with a basil Alfredo sauce. “Era Delizioso!” Ok let me back up, I was served up a salad as well with warm bread. The salad was very fresh yet simple. I read a review on here that someone didn’t get enough dressing, mine came in a cup on the side (I appreciate little things like that) and it was plenty of dressing. I do wish a little more effort was put into the salad itself however. It came on plate slightly too small and the vegetables seemed to be quickly thrown on the side. I highly doubt this is a style, but who knows, I could be wrong and this is just how they do it here. Alright, fast forwarding to dessert. ...WOW... I was extremely surprised! When I asked for a cannoli I just wanted one (because at that point I was stuffed from the Shrimp Genovese, but I can always make room for dessert) and I was expecting a bland Ricotta filled cannoli, because VERY few places get it right. Well, I’m proud to tell you, that I’ve found a restaurant that has a perfect Cannoli. They said they don’t make the shells themselves, but they do make the cream/Ricotta mixture. It was topped with chocolate syrup which my waitress agreed that that’s what makes all the difference. My waitress, Debbie, was attentive, kind, and well informed. She asked me how my food was periodically, but not overly so. The service was quick for a Monday night. It just goes to show once again, Saranac Lake is filled with hidden gems like this one. I’ll be back for more....!
We came for dinner on July 4th, it was busy but we were seated right away. My husband and I ordered a pasta dish; each dish was delicious. Our waitress was attentive. We haven’t stopped talking about our meals!
Great New York style pizza by the slice or you can get a whole pie. I got 2 slices of cheese with pepperoni on them they were slipped into the oven to them hot and brought out they were great. You can eat in or take out they have mini calzones and a couple other choices. I came for some New York slices and was not disappointed. Great pie friendly help what more is there if your in Saranac Lake, NY stop and get yourself a slice. I didn't take pictures of the place or my slices as honestly I was hungry and forgot and I think everyone knows what New York style pie looks like. Just an update on my past review Little Italy Pizzeria & Restaurant is still great the pizza is still outstanding and you can't beat there meatball sub. But the picture they show on the first page of Google Maps is incorrect they have the address correct which points to the new location but pictures are wrong I have added new pictures of the new location. I believe they have more seating also at the new location at 151 River St.
I love it so much !! The workers are so kind and very personable. The food is delicious! We will definitely be going back soon! keep up the great work !
Location
-
151 River St, Saranac Lake, NY 12983, United States Hotline: +1 518-891-9000
Nestled along the scenic River Street in Saranac Lake, **Little Italy Pizzeria & Restaurant** is a delightful haven for food enthusiasts. As you approach this charming establishment, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza mingled with savory Italian fare beckons you to come inside. With a phone number readily available at +1 518-891-9000, it's no wonder that locals and visitors alike regard this spot as a must-try destination for hearty meals and a cozy atmosphere.
Upon entering, guests are often surprised by the warm and inviting dining area that balances coziness with spaciousness. The tall ceilings and soft rock music create a relaxed vibe, perfect for either a casual dinner or a special occasion. The reviews speak volumes; customers rave about the fast service and the extensive variety of offerings beyond just pizza. From baked pastas and subs to crisp salads and delectable desserts, Little Italy caters to diverse palates, making it more than just a pizzeria.
One standout element is the restaurant's commitment to quality. Reviewers have highlighted dishes like the **Shrimp Genovese**, showcasing fresh ingredients like artichoke hearts and roasted red peppers over linguine, all enveloped in a luscious basil Alfredo sauce. This dish exemplifies the restaurant's ability to surprise diners with exquisite flavors that elevate the dining experience.
If you’re craving something sweet to round off your meal, you must try their **cannoli**. Although the shells may not be made in-house, the creamy ricotta filling is expertly crafted, often receiving high praise for its flavor and texture. Drizzled with chocolate syrup, this dessert has become a beloved favorite among visitors, leaving them eager for a return trip just for another taste.
While the restaurant operates on a **cash-only** basis and doesn't serve pizza slices during sit-down meals, the opportunity to take home a slice after dining adds a charming twist for those who want to savor more of what Little Italy has to offer. With attentive servers like Sky and Debbie, who enhance the dining experience with their kindness and promptness, it is no wonder guests feel welcome and valued.
In summary, **Little Italy Pizzeria & Restaurant** is more than just a place to grab a pizza; it's a delightful experience characterized by top-notch food, exceptional service, and a cozy ambiance. As one reviewer aptly put it, "Saranac Lake is filled with hidden gems," and this pizzeria is certainly a prime example. Whether you're a local or visiting, make sure to stop by and relish the flavors that await you!